Is my data out of reach of US law if the server is in Europe?
A server has an address. The company that runs it has a passport. People tend to ask about the first and forget the second.
The question matters because of a US law from 2018 called the CLOUD Act. It settled an argument that had gone all the way to the Supreme Court, about an email kept in a data centre in Ireland. The outcome, as the US Department of Justice describes it, is that providers under US jurisdiction have to hand over data that a valid US legal order asks for, wherever the company keeps it. European data protection authorities read the law the same way: it reaches providers under US jurisdiction irrespective of where the data is stored.
So "hosted in Frankfurt" answers where the disks are. It does not answer whose courts can send the company a warrant.
Some proportion helps here. This is a law about criminal investigations, and it works through legal process, not through someone browsing your folders. A provider can contest an order in certain cases. Many practices will decide the risk is small for what they hold. But a practice that keeps other people's confidential files should at least know which of its tools the question applies to, because the people in those files never got a say.
The useful questions are about ownership. Who owns the company that runs the service, and who owns them? Where is the parent incorporated? If a European company was bought last year, by whom? A tool can be European by address and American by ownership, and the other way round.
You do not have to act on the answers. Knowing them changes very little about your Tuesday and quite a lot about what you can honestly tell a client who asks where their file lives.
Last checked 16 November 2026. Information, not legal advice.